This article is written by Arya Pandey, third year BBA LLB student at Navrachana University, Vadodara during her internship at LeDroit India.
KEYWORDS
Limited Liability, Liability, Company, Shareholders, Shares, Members, Debts.
ABSTRACT
The concept of Limited Liability refers to a legal principle that protects the shareholders from being personally liable for the debts of the company. This concept restricts the liability of members only up to the amount of shares they have invested in the company, beyond which there exists no personal liability upon them. This concept protects the rights of the shareholders but at the same time has many disadvantages, which needs to be discussed and solved. This article aims to show the significance of the concept of limited liability and at the same time focuses on highlighting the loopholes that are often neglected and have the potential to cause a huge harm in future. This article delves into the key aspects of limited liability, and equips the readers with a comprehensive understanding of this concept.
THE PRINCIPLE OF LIMITED LIABILITY
Limited Liability is a structure in a company that proposes the liability of shareholders of the company are only limited to the value of their personal share. No shareholder can be held liable beyond such value. This concept protects the shareholders at times when the company is in huge debt or the company is on the verge of bankruptcy, by limiting their liability towards the company.
A limited company’s incorporation offers directors and shareholders individual financial and legal security against any potential business insolvency problems.
This concept is an advantage from a company’s perspective as it promotes shareholders to invest and participate in the growth of the company, without having a risk if the company fails. Limited Liability assures that the personal assets of the members of the company won’t be seized in order to repay the debt attributed to the company. The concept promises the personal assets of the shareholders of the company would be intact at the time of financial crisis or bankruptcy of the company.
A firm with limited liability is regarded as a separate legal entity from its owners. This means that the company itself, rather than the people who own or manage it, is liable for any debts or legal claims against it.
How does limited liability work?
To benefit from limited liability, a business must be organized as an incorporated corporation. Some of the most prevalent types of businesses with limited liability include:
Private Limited Company (Ltd) – A company owned by private shareholders whose liability is limited to the value of their shares.
A public limited corporation (PLC) is one that sells its shares to the general public via stock exchanges, providing stockholders with limited liability.
Limited Liability Company (LLC) – A hybrid organization used in the United States that combines elements of corporations and partnerships.
A limited liability partnership (LLP) is one in which each partner’s liability is restricted to their agreed-upon stake in the business.
Once a corporation is registered as a limited liability entity, it has legal separation from its owners, which ensures that its financial obligations do not extend to the shareholders’ personal assets.
Types of Limited Liability Structures
There are many types of limited liability structures depending on corporate goals and legal frameworks:
1. Sole proprietorship vs. limited liability.
Sole proprietorships do not offer limited liability protection, putting personal assets at risk. Limited liability structures, such as LLCs and Ltd firms, shield owners from commercial debts.
2. Limited Liability vs. Unlimited Liability Businesses
Unlimited liability firms render the owners personally accountable for all obligations.
Limited liability firms keep personal and corporate finances apart, protecting the owners.
3. Limited Liability across Jurisdictions
Different countries have different legal frameworks for limited liability.
In the United States, LLCs are common, whilst in the United Kingdom, Ltd corporations are dominant. Some governments apply additional tax breaks or regulatory compliance requirements.
ADVANTAGES OF LIMITED LIABILITY
This principle brings many advantages that promotes the growth and success of the company. Some of the advantages are:-
- Protection of personal assets of the shareholders
A company is treated as a separate legal entity, distinct from its directors and shareholders, which makes the liability of the shareholders limited only up to the value of shares invested by them, thus protecting their personal assets such as homes and savings, remain protected in the event of the company’s insolvency or lawsuits. This reduces personal financial risk, encouraging entrepreneurship and investment.
- Promotes Investment and Growth of Business
When a shareholder gets to control the functioning of the company without having to invest their personal asset at the time of repayment of debts of the company, this brings a sense of security to the shareholders and encourages them to strive towards growing the company leading to its success.
- Easy Access to loans and credits
Financial Institutions are more interested in giving credits to limited liability, because the creditors get the security that on meeting failure they can claim the assets of the company and get their money back, hence this concept ensures securing financial help easier.
- Financial Flexibility
Companies with limited liability enjoy financial flexibility that other forms of companies don’t. Limited liability corporations frequently benefit from tax breaks. For example, LLCs and corporations can deduct business expenses, salaries, and other operational costs before paying taxes. Additionally, some countries have lower corporate tax rates than individual income tax rates.
- Perpetual succession
A limited liability business exists in perpetuity, which means that changes in ownership, the death of a shareholder, or the resignation of directors have no effect on its legal standing. This ensures the continuity and stability of corporate activities.
- Legal Protection against Business Debts
Unlike sole proprietorships and traditional partnerships, limited liability companies offer legal protection from personal liability for corporate debts. This means that, even in bankruptcy, creditors cannot seize shareholders’ personal assets in excess of their investment.
- Increased credibility and business stability.
A limited liability entity provides legitimacy to a firm, making it more appealing to consumers, suppliers, and financiers. Many businesses and financial institutions prefer to work with incorporated firms because they have organized governance and transparency.
DISADVANTAGES OF LIMITED LIABILITY
This concept of Limited Liability is an advantage for the company and its shareholders, but the features of the concept sets forward questions that have been raised, some of which falls as a disadvantage of the principle.
- Limited Liability is not an absolute protection
If in case it is found that the shareholders have misused their right or committed fraud, the court may overturn this principle and ask them to replay the debt from their personal asset, this principle would fail in such cases and the shareholders will have to repay the debts of the company from their personal assets.
- Risk Involvement gets higher
Shareholders with limited liability, tend to take higher risks in the business as they are only liable for the sarees they have invested, and this might lead them to aggressively take harsh decisions that might bring the company at higher risks.
- Administrative Burden
Forming and running a limited liability company incurs additional expenditures and tight regulatory procedures. Registering and running a limited liability company incurs substantial administrative and financial costs. Companies must pay registration, legal, and annual compliance fees, which can be costly for small enterprises.
- Lack of personal commitment
Limited liability may lessen a shareholder’s commitment to the company’s long-term success because investors are not directly liable for business debts, some may take their investment lightly. Sole proprietors and unlimited liability partners, on the other hand, have a stronger personal stake in the success of their businesses.
- Public Disclosure of Financial Information
Limited liability corporations, particularly PLCs, are required to publicly disclose financial statements and annual reports. This lack of privacy might reveal a company’s financial position to competitors, affecting its strategic activities.
- Compliance and Regulatory Requirements
Limited liability entities are subject to higher legal and regulatory constraints than sole proprietorships or general partnerships. Annual filings, financial statement disclosure, and compliance with corporate governance regulations are all examples of time-consuming and costly tasks.
- Difficulties in obtaining debt financing.
Limited liability firms can raise capital through share issuance, but obtaining debt funding from banks can be difficult. Many financial organizations seek personal guarantees from directors or large shareholders before accepting loans, reducing the benefits of restricted liability.
JUDICIAL TAKE ON LIMITED LIABILITY
It’s important to discuss the take of the judiciary on the concept of limited liability. Several legal cases have shaped the interpretation and application of limited liability:
- Salomon v Salomon & Co. Ltd (1897) – This case established the principle that a company is a separate legal entity from its owners, reinforcing the concept of limited liability.
- Gilford Motor Co. Ltd v Horne (1933) – The court lifted the corporate veil when a former employee set up a separate company to avoid contractual obligations.
- Jones v Lipman (1962) – The corporate veil was pierced when a shareholder attempted to use a company as a façade to avoid a property sale obligation.
These cases demonstrate that while limited liability offers protection, it is not absolute and can be disregarded in instances of fraud or abuse. The court in these cases lifted the corporate veil and held the shareholders personally liable for wrongful actions.
CONCLUSION
Limited liability is an important feature of corporation law that protects financial assets, encourages investment, and promotes economic growth. However, it is not without obstacles. While it protects shareholders from personal liability, it introduces new risks including moral hazard, regulatory hurdles, and possibly legal obligations.
Businesses must conduct ethically and maintain corporate transparency to avoid legal ramifications such as penetrating the corporate veil. Understanding the benefits and drawbacks of limited liability allows entrepreneurs and investors to make informed decisions about structuring their businesses for long-term success.
Finally, the concept of limited liability finds a compromise between promoting economic progress and holding corporations accountable, making it a necessary component of modern commerce.
Reference
